Table. 5.
Measurement Error data of the studies
| Body Part | Study | Proprioception outcome | SEM | MDC | LoA | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hip | Arvin et al. 2015 [12] | JPS: Flexion | RE: .71°–1.03° AE: .63°–.72° VE: .66°–.94° |
NS | RE: -2.99°, 2.74°(Lt.)/-2.05°, 1.9°(Rt.) AE: -1.86°, 2.16°(Lt.)/-1.43°, 2.06°(Rt.) VE: -1.83°, 1.81°(Lt.)/-3.01°, 2.17°(Rt.) |
||
| JPS: Abduction | RE: .48°–.96° AE: .39°–.67° VE: .54°–.68° |
NS | RE: -1.51°, 1.13°(Lt.)/-2.95°, 2.39°(Rt.) AE: -1.45°, .70°(Lt.)/-2.26°, 1.43°(Rt.) VE:-2.14°, 1.62°(Lt.)/-.89°, 2.09°(Rt.) |
||||
| Knee | JPS: Flexion | RE: 2.20°–2.71° AE: 1.61°–1.68° VE: 1.42°–2.08° |
NS | NS | RE: -6.82°, 5.36°((Lt.)/-7.12°, 7.89°(Rt.) AE: -4.49°, 4.44°(Lt.)/-4.06°, 5.26(Rt.) VE: -5.79°, 5.73°(Lt.)/-3.15°, 4.73°(Rt.) |
||
| Baert et al. 2018 [11] | JPS: 20°, 45°, 70° Flexion | Inter-rater reliability KOA: 1 without KOA: 1 |
Intrarater reliability KOA: 1 without KOA: 1-2 |
Inter-rater reliability KOA: 3 without KOA: 3 |
Intrarater reliability KOA: 3-4 without KOA: 4 |
NS | |
| KFS: 25%, 50%, 75% force | Inter-rater reliability KOA: 7.4 without KOA: 10.7 |
Intrarater reliability KOA: 4.8-9.6 without KOA: 6.6-10.8 |
Inter-rater reliability KOA: 20.6 without KOA: 29.6 |
Intrarater reliability KOA: 13.2-26.7 without KOA: 18.3-29.9 |
NS | ||
SEM = Standard Error of Measurement, MDC = Minimal Detectable Change, LoA = Limits of Agreement, JPS = Joint Position Sense, NS = Not stated, RE = Relative Error, AE = Absolute Error, VE = Variable Error, KOA = Knee Osteoarthritis KFS = Knee Force Sense
J Korean Soc Phys Med 2024;19:47-57 https://doi.org/10.13066/kspm.2024.19.4.47 
© 2024 J Korean Soc Phys Med